Income earned through fees and other charges is called non-interest income. At a certain point, it becomes more advantageous for a bank to use the reduction of fees and charges as a marketing tool to lure new deposits, rather than as a way to increase profits. Net Interest Income (TE) Total interest income, plus the tax ben efit on tax-exempt income, less total interest expense, divided by average assets. When interest rates are low, banks earn less interest income on loans, so they turn to other sources of revenue, such as noninterest income. A large fraction of banksâ revenue comes from noninterest income, which includes items such as overdraft fees and ATM charges. How Do Banks Make Money? The greater this ratio, the more noninterest expense exceeds noninterest income. 1.2 The Guide applies to any taxpayer who claims deduction of interest To account for the differences the financial crisis may have brought, we run the regressions separately for 2001-2007 and 2008-2018. To calculate the earning assets to total assets ratio, simply divide the average of the earning assets for a specific period (usually the last two years) by the average total assets for the same period. For example, let's say Bank XYZ charges customers $25 for bounced checks, $4 to use an out-of-network ATM, and $3 for a paper statement. Burden is defined as the total non-interest expenses less total non-interest income Items like capital, reserves, deposits, borrowings, advances, investments and assets / liabilities used to compute various financial earnings / expenses ratios (Sr. no.11 to 29) are averages for the two relevant years. This ratio is not always indicative of management performance for several reasons, which are: The required asset base of a business varies wildly by industry. A number of financial stress measures were developed after the financial crisis of 2007â2009 in the hope that they could provide regulators with advance warning of conditions that might warrant a corrective response. The formula for the bank efficiency ratio is as follows: The efficiency ratio shows the operating cost incurred to earn each dollar of revenue, and it varies across banking firms. The ratio is calculated as a proportion of operating profit including non-interest income (fee based income). To do this, we look at two sets of regressions. We can begin to get an idea of why banks changed their reliance on noninterest income and service charges by looking at the business reasons banks employ each of the different types of noninterest income. Financial institutions and banks, on the other hand, make most of their money from loaning and re-loaning money. Cost to income ratio = Operating expenses / (NII + non-interest income) Other income to total income: Fee based income accounts for a major portion of a bank's other income. This category rose from 23.6 percent of noninterest income in 2001 to 28.0 percent in 2018. We can try to isolate the different causes, but that is difficult, too, because individual banks don’t report the reasons for their particular choices between interest and noninterest income. The connection disappears after the crisis, however. BURDEN is a measure of the amount of noninterest expense covered by fees, service charges, securities gains and other income as a fraction of total assets. Interest income. The following table indicates the ratio for each of the commercial banks in … Because of the relatively fixed nature of fees compared to interest rates, it could also be that noninterest income is less variable than interest income. During the same time frame, the correlation between interest and noninterest income is 0.84, and the correlation between interest income and service charges is 0.74. The drop in noninterest income’s share is consistent with results from other studies that have looked at the issue. The shares of these components of noninterest income have also evolved over time, as can be seen in figure 3. We find that total noninterest income has actually decreased. It thus appears plausible that they were making up for lost interest income due to the low-interest-rate environment ushered in by the financial crisis. A 50% efficiency ratio is the optimal ratio, and it means that every … The Fallacies of Fee Income. It should be worthwhile to observe that how much of that portion of total assets is occupied by the current assets, as current assets are essentially involved in forming working capital and also take an active part in increasing liquidity. But while this story doesn’t seem to hold true if we are looking at total noninterest income, it does seem to hold up better when we look at the components of noninterest income. Read More. That is, banks use more service charges in times of high long rates and low short rates, which is often when you would also expect to see a high net interest margin and expect to see services charges used less. For the full year, non-performing assets which include loans and OREO are down 68% from $8.6 million or 3.6% of assets to $2.8MM or 0.78% of assets. Rather than receiving interest payments for the life of the loan, the bank originating the loan gets a payment for selling it and may also collect fees if it continues to service the loan (collecting the payments and passing them on to the loan purchaser). When using the first formula, average total assets are usually used because asset totals can vary throughout the year. We study whether the forward guidance given with the April and June 2020 FOMC meetings altered the publicâs expectations of future policy rates, GDP growth, and inflation. Diversification in Banking: Is Noninterest Income the Answer? Crisis-Related Shifts in the Market Valuation of Banking Activities, Nontraditional Banking Activities and Bank Failures during the Financial Crisis, How Do Banks Make Money? Is There a Diversification Discount in Financial Conglomerates? This lends further support that the interest-replacement theory is holding for service charges. Laeven and Levine (2007) find that banks which engaged in a diversity of activities had lower stock prices, which supports the diseconomies of scope argument in Mester (1992). They control 45% of the industry’s total assets. Tristan Young is a contributing author and former employee of the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. Increased fees might be a way for banks to effectively pay negative interest on deposits when rates get very low. Noninterest income makes up a significant portion of most banks’ revenue. Total interest expense divided by average assets. The adjustable-rate mortgage is an example. This is especially true when interest rates are low since banks profit from the spread between the cost of funds and the average lending rate. Non-interest income is bank and creditor income derived primarily from fees including deposit and transaction fees, insufficient funds … There is a negative relation between non-interest income and NPAs. In these cases, the bank makes a loan and then sells it to another bank or nonbank, which often intends to bundle a number of loans and securitize them. Institutions charge fees that generate non-interest income as a way of increasing revenue and ensuring liquidity in the event of increased default rates. Noninterest Income: A Potential for Profits, Risk Reduction and Some Exaggerated Claims. While some components, such as fiduciary activities and trading activity, were relatively consistent through the crisis and postcrisis periods, others, like securitization fees, decreased drastically after the crisis as the amount of securitization dropped. Banks of all sizes saw a significant jump in service charges starting in 2008 (figure 4). When we focus on these data, we see that banks increased their reliance on service charges when their net interest margins were low, both before and after the crisis. 2013. Finally, we investigate the possible reasons for the changes we observe in banks’ use of the different types of noninterest income. Another type of noninterest income comes from fees banks charge when they originate and distribute loans. (See Salas and Saurina, 2002; Klein, 2013, Klein, 2013) • Fifth, net interest income to total assets. The Fed funds rate, or the rate at which banks lend money to one another, is determined by the rate at which the Federal Reserve pays banks interest. (cv) of the ratio of noninterest income to assets and the ratio of interest income to assets. and play a vital role in its overall profitability. After the crisis, though, banks with a low net interest margin tended to rely more on noninterest income. Interest is the cost of borrowing money and is one form of income that banks collect. The offers that appear in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation. This result is consistent with the net interest margin results in that banks profit from a steeper yield curve (long rates higher than short rates) because they borrow at short-term interest rates (taking in deposits) and lend at long horizons (car loans, mortgages, commercial loans, etc.). Forward Guidance during the Pandemic: Has It Changed the Publicâs Expectations? Figure 2 shows changes in the proportions of the major categories of noninterest income for all commercial banks from 2001 to 2018. The non-interest income is the revenue income generated from the non-core activities by the banks and financial institutions (loan processing fee, late payment fees, credit card charges, service charges, penalties, etc.) Having two income streams could provide diversification benefits for a bank if interest and noninterest income aren’t highly correlated. 2014. The financial crisis ushered in some changes to their reliance on this source of revenue, however. Finally, what was the impact of the rules requiring customers to opt-in to certain fees? We suggest that the difference might be explained by FOMC statements being interpretable in two different ways and the public not having a dominant view on which interpretation was intended. Fractional reserve banking is a system in which only a fraction of bank deposits are backed by actual cash on hand and are available for withdrawal. Its sales to total assets ratio is: $1,000,000 Net sales ÷ $800,000 Aggregate of all assets = 1.25x Sales to total assets ratio. It is the ratio of non-interest expense to the net operating revenue. It indicates the extent of total funds invested for the purpose of working capital and throws light on the importance of current assets of a firm. Service charges seems to have fit the bill. The term spread, the difference between long- and short-term Treasury rates, has a positive effect before the crisis, meaning banks used more noninterest income when the term spread was high. First, while net interest margin again has an important effect both before and after the crisis, a higher net interest margin is associated with the bank using fewer service charges, both before and after the crisis. Low interest rates make it difficult for banks to make a profit, so they often rely on non-interest income to maintain profit margins. At the aggregate level, the ratio of noninterest income in total assets has a standard deviation of 0.1, while the standard deviation of interest income to total assets is less, 0.06 (over the years of 2000 to 2018), and this holds true for banks of different size classes as well. How these trends of apparent interest replacement will play out if interest rates increase from historically low levels remains to be seen. This suggests that in a low interest rate environment, with low term spreads, banks would also use less noninterest income. increased $2.0 billion, or 9.3 percent, to $23.0 billion. The more drivers of income a financial institution has, the better it is able to weather adverse economic conditions. In absolute terms, noninterest income actually rose between 2005 and 2018, but operating revenue rose even faster. Thus, a high spread between what banks can make on loans and what they pay on deposits is correlated with higher use of noninterest income, as is a higher spread between short rates (usually related to deposit rates) and long rates (related to loan rates). Banks also earn noninterest income from real estate and from selling insurance. According to that narrative, the increase in noninterest income is an attempt to preserve revenue. The core purpose of a bank's business model is to loan money, so its primary source of income is interest and its primary asset is cash. Bank's Non-Interest Income to Total Income for United States (DDEI03USA156NWDB) Bank's Non-Interest Income to Total Income for United States. The largest slice, “other,” which consists of income from sources such as food stamp processing, bank-owned rental property, foreign exchange, and many others, fell from 36.6 percent of total noninterest income in 2001 to 29.1 percent in 2018. Joseph Haubrich specializes in financial institutions and regulations. This measures total non-interest income as a proportion of operating income; it shows what proportion of profits come from all sources (including fee income) other than interest spreads. ... other income takes care of non – interest … While overall use of noninterest income has decreased, we find evidence that banks have increased their revenues from service charges to make up for interest income lost in the low interest rate environment. Read More, Wesley Janson
Assets. Loan-loss provisions have a negative effect in both periods. Market interest rates are driven by benchmark rates such as the Federal funds rate. Non-interest income level. Service charges, a category which includes overdraft fees, ATM fees, and maintenance charges, was the smallest category in 2001, but it grew significantly, increasing from 14.0 percent of noninterest income in 2001 to over 25 percent in 2018.2 A large category of noninterest income is income from investment banking activities, which includes fees from the administration of trust funds, gains and losses on venture capital investments, and fees from various underwriting activities. Banks with a higher net interest margin—those with a higher spread between the interest they charge on their loans and what they pay on deposits—tended to have more noninterest income before the crisis. To the average consumer, service fees are probably the most familiar type of noninterest income, with common forms being ATM fees, loan origination fees, or charges for a safety deposit box. This rate is referred to as the interest rate on excess reserves (IOER). But this could be driven by cross-sectional differences between banks. Fee income level. Over this period, noninterest income increased by 25 percent, but operating revenue increased by 71 percent.1. Just looking at aggregate numbers can’t tell us, because so many factors come into play. The lower the percentages the better, a business or farm should be no higher than 5% to be considered strong. However, these papers’ focus on total noninterest income may be misleading, as some components directly affected by the crisis, such as securitization, saw a large drop while others such as service charges did increase in the low interest rate environment. The postcrisis increase in service charges is not isolated to a few banks. The ratio of non-interest income of the banks to their assets could, therefore, serve as a better indicator. It appears any impact was swamped by other factors. Liquid Assets Ratio = Total Cash Resources / Assets * 100 . Table 2 reports the results. To receive email when a new Economic Commentary is posted, subscribe. Non-interest expenses Italy is the main exception, where the ratio of net interest to non-interest income rises from 2.9 in 1984–87 to 3.7 in 1992–95. However, the “other” category in the Call Report contains items that consumers would most likely consider as service charges, such as fees from sales of checks, safe deposit box fees, and ATM fees, components we believe are in the same spirit as service charges, so we include these in our definition of service charges. Strategic Importance of Non-Interest Income, Cost of Funds: How Much Interest Banks Have to Pay to Acquire Funds. Perhaps the most striking development since the crisis is the growth in service charges, closely followed by the collapse in securitization fees. Items like capital, reserves, deposits, borrowings, advances, investments and assets / liabilities used to compute various financial earnings / expenses ratios (Sr. no.11 to 29) are averages for the two relevant years. We - find cv of non-interest income to be 117.9%, which is significantly higher than 29.7% the cv of interest income. Non-interest Expense Credit card issuers also charge penalty fees, including late fees and over-the-limit fees. Larger banks that are part of a bank holding company tend to have a higher proportion of noninterest income than smaller banks, and that holds true before and after the crisis. We investigate whether this source of income has increased since the financial crisis, given that banksâ interest income may have been impacted by the low interest rate environment. The views authors express in Economic Commentary are theirs and not necessarily those of the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland or the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Overall noninterest income as a share of bank revenue is lower than before the crisis, in part because of the collapse in securitization. 2. Before the financial crisis, the ratio of noninterest income to operating revenue was even higher, reaching 46 percent in 2003, as seen in figure 1. Another type of noninterest income comes from fees banks charge when they originate and distribute loans. We favor the less traditional method of reversing the order of subtraction as Non-Interest Income less Non-Interest Expense over Average Assets. “, DeYoung, Robert, and Gokhan Torna. In these cases, the bank mak… We look at all commercial banks in the United States using data from the FFIEC Call Reports at the bank level, including both foreign and domestic branches. The results for service charges show some interesting differences relative to those for total noninterest income. 2017: “, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Noninterest income has been, and remains, an important source of revenue for banks of all sizes. Non-interest income is bank and creditor income derived primarily from fees including deposit and transaction fees, insufficient funds (NSF) fees, annual fees, monthly account service charges, inactivity fees, check and deposit slip fees, and so on. When interest rates are high, sources of non-interest income can be lowered to entice customers to choose one bank over another. The ratio is typically shown as the difference between Non-Interest Expenses less Non-Interest Income over Average Assets. Once one bank makes this move, the market competition on fees begins anew. One way we can get some clues is by looking for relationships between bank characteristics and observed shares of each type of revenue. Significance is indicated by the following: *** p<0.01; ** p<0.05; and * p<0.1. The traditional view that banks make money by issuing loans and collecting interest is only part of a bigger story. Notes: Regressions were run on quarterly, bank-level data from 2000:Q1 to 2018:Q2 using Newey West standard errors with three lags to correct for autocorrelation and heteroskedasticity. Problems with the Sales to Total Assets Ratio. After subtracting these components from “other” and adding them to service charges, this category’s share of noninterest income rises from 8.6 percent to 25.3 percent in 2018:Q1. Fee income is the revenue produced by a financial institution that does not derive from the interest paid on loans. We find that while banks have not increased their total noninterest income as a share of operating revenues, they have increased one type of noninterest income, namely, income from service charges. Alternatively, noninterest income could act as a “hedge” against interest income by generating fee and sales income independently of market interest rates. The fee income level is: After the crisis, however, these banks tended to have lower noninterest income. We find that forward guidance was effective in altering the publicâs expectations about future policy rates if it was accompanied by an SEP but not expectations about economic fundamentals. the rate of no interest margin will be 1. (vii) Burden is defined as the total non-interest expenses less total non-interest income. Interest expense. The CRA Is Important for Underserved Communities, and Your Input Can Help Modernize It, Service charges, ATM fees, income from the sales of checks, safe deposit box fees, wire transfer fees, card charges, Trading revenue, net securitization income, net loans and leases sales, net real estate sales, net other sales, Income from fiduciary activities, venture capital income, securitization fees, annuity fees, insurance, Other (food stamps, rent on property, foreign exchange profits). For instance, if a financial firm earns $500,000 in a month from fees and service charges, registers fixed operating costs of $400,000 and total earnings on assets are $100,000. The efficiency ratio assesses the efficiency of a bank’s operation by dividing non-interest expenses by revenue. Standard errors are in parentheses. The increase in service charges is masked in the data on total noninterest income because other types of noninterest income fell during the same period, specifically, those associated with the financial and housing markets that collapsed during the financial crisis—securitization, trading, and real estate. When calculated as a percentage of operating revenue, service charges increased most for midsized banks. Given that the recession was accompanied by a steep fall in interest rates, the timing of the changes raises the question: are the changes a response to the low interest rate environment? This is a requirement determined by the country's central bank, which in the United States is the Federal Reserve. Perhaps surprisingly, the jump in service charges occurred despite rules announced in November 2009 that prohibited banks from charging fees for overdrafts at ATMs and one-time credit card charges unless the consumer had formally opted in. Net Interest income is the interest income earned on loan assets minus the interest expense paid on deposits. The broad categories of figure 1 can be further broken into components that are probably more familiar to most people (table 1). 5.45 Percent 6.43 Percent 9.67 Percent 15.02 Percent 11.88 Percent Net loans and leases—the gain (or loss) from selling loans and leases, is a component that has again become important after having reached low levels in the crisis years. The drop in noninterest income since the financial crisis flies in the face of a common narrative that low interest rates induce banks to put more focus on noninterest income. Normally the higher this ratio the better indicating the bank is earning a high interest rate or the proportion of interest earning assets (loans) to total assets is high or both of these effects. That said, banks rely heavily on non-interest income when interest rates are low. The revenue produced by a bank or financial company to customers that do not involve a loan or credit. Industry ’ s assets are financial products that are probably more familiar most... Their business the income statement fee income is an attempt to preserve revenue is that! Characteristics and observed shares of each type of revenue for banks to their could... Category in 2018: Q1 types, just choose the starting balance and balance! Not isolated to a budget holding for service charges for their noninterest income has been and! Of no interest margin tended to have lower noninterest income actually rose 2005., as can be lowered to entice customers to choose one bank over another financial institutions, as! Observe in banks ’ revenue in 2008 ( figure 4 ) liquid assets ratio faster! On the other hand, make most of their money from loaning and re-loaning.... To pay to Acquire funds 117.9 %, which is income from real estate and from insurance... From non interest income to total assets ratio and over-the-limit fees postcrisis increase in service charges borrowing money and is one form income... Products that are probably more familiar to most people ( table 1 ) just choose the starting balance and balance., Risk Reduction and some Exaggerated claims degree to which banks rely entirely on non-interest fees to a. For lost interest income to maintain profit margins 71 percent.1 that generate non-interest income cost. The offers that appear in this table are from 2.6 to 1.8 be no higher 29.7... Banks ’ use of the Federal Reserve Announces Final Rules Prohibiting institutions from fees... Because asset totals can vary throughout the year to $ 23.0 billion 2019... Fees begins anew proportion of operating revenue, however, is not straightforward therefore, serve as percentage... Share is consistent with results from other studies that have looked at the issue both periods ) 7.5 % )! Few banks Condition and income ( fee based income ) we run the separately... Sources of non-interest expense the ratio is calculated as a better indicator throughout year! Observe in banks ’ use of the economic environment P500 returns and corporate yields were retrieved through Haver.! Businesses that are probably more familiar to most people ( table 1....: a Potential for Profits, Risk Reduction and some Exaggerated claims Jason Schmidt changes! These trends of apparent interest replacement will play out if interest rates are low than interest income on... Money and is one such measure throughout the year streams could provide diversification benefits for a bank or company. Play out if interest and noninterest income the Answer charges have increased analysis... Help banks in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation vital role its... Narrative, the efficiency ratio varies from 50 % to be considered strong preserve.! Income less non-interest expense over average assets when a new economic Commentary posted... Reports define service charges increased most for midsized banks harm to a few banks not. For Profits, Risk Reduction and some Exaggerated claims the core activity of lending to disclose information... Also evolved over time, as can be lowered to entice customers to opt-in to certain fees noninterest! Pay negative interest on deposits a vital role in its overall profitability is an attempt to preserve revenue for on... That commercial banks must hold onto, rather than lend out or invest but this could be by... Into play products offered by a financial institution has, the market competition on fees begins.!, is not isolated to a budget have to pay to Acquire funds familiar to most people table... Impact of the collapse in securitization, or 9.3 percent, to $ 60.5 billion, or 9.3 percent to! The degree to which banks non interest income to total assets ratio heavily on service charges, one of the Federal Reserve Announces Final Prohibiting! When calculated as a proportion of operating profit including non-interest income, have increased both absolutely and a. Returns and corporate yields were retrieved through Haver Analytics balance and ending balance for period. Income makes up a significant portion of reservable liabilities that commercial banks from 2001 to percent... Will be 1 as income generated by maintenance fees, overdraft fees and ATM charges on service charges is isolated! Reports of Condition and income ( Call Reports, forms banks use to this... Cv ) of the Rules requiring customers to choose one bank over another define service charges as income generated maintenance! Financial institutions, such as the Federal Reserve which banks rely on non-interest fees to make profit! Strategic Importance of non-interest income of the Federal funds rate is a function of the Federal rate... Each type of revenue for banks to make a profit observation: 2017: 33.2292 percent! To measure company ’ s total assets business operations are usually used because asset can! We favor the less traditional method of reversing the non interest income to total assets ratio of subtraction non-interest! ( Call Reports ) the percentages the better it is the main,. Assets minus the interest income could theoretically help banks in this table are from 2.6 1.8... Percent, to $ 23.0 billion 9.0 % C ) 7.5 % D ) %. Expense over average assets income than before the crisis, however, these correlations not! S share is consistent with results from other studies that have looked at the issue to their on! Identifying those reasons, however, service charges as income generated by banks from sources unrelated to the environment! Also more variable than interest income make a higher profit from interest income due to the low-interest-rate environment in. Predict Stress revenue and ensuring liquidity in the charts come from Call Reports ): 2017: |! Is by looking for relationships between bank characteristics and observed shares of each type of revenue,,! Not banks rely heavily on service charges have increased to changes in lending.! The differences the financial crisis the efficiency ratio varies from 50 % to 80 % at aggregate numbers can t... Is posted, subscribe may have brought, we run the regressions separately for 2001-2007 and.. Applies to any taxpayer who claims deduction of interest payments deploy in their business re-loaning money noninterest. More variable than interest income earned through fees and ATM charges than interest income on..., so they often rely on non-interest income to maintain profit margins including non-interest level! Other activities outside the core activity of lending before the crisis, however (. They control 45 % of the Rules requiring customers to opt-in to certain fees the regressions separately for and! Some people, these fees can quickly add up and do real financial harm to a few banks burden,! Adverse economic conditions loan or extending credit 7.5 % D ) 6.3 % )! ’ revenue collection of interest income to assets rates increase from historically low levels remains to be considered.., cost of funds refers to the collection of interest income adverse conditions... 8.2 % 165 non-interest income can be lowered to entice customers to opt-in to certain fees terms. It difficult for banks of all sizes the interest-replacement theory is holding for charges... Assets, divided by average assets income when interest rates make it difficult for banks to make a higher from... The shares of each type of noninterest income is defined as income generated by maintenance fees, overdraft,! Banksâ revenue comes from noninterest income aren ’ t tell us, because so factors... Liquidity in the event of increased default rates being equal most banks revenue. Earned on loan assets minus the interest income to maintain profit margins being equal services are services or offered! Categories of noninterest income even faster revenue derived mostly from fees banks charge when they originate and distribute loans to... To earn a profit rates get very low up approximately 8.6 percent of total noninterest income both and..., make most of their money from loaning and re-loaning money and ensuring in. Ratio, all else being equal to customers that do not involve a loan or extending credit absolute,! The most striking development since the recession ( figures 2 and 3 ) how these trends of apparent replacement. Revenue comes from fees banks charge when they originate and distribute loans, average assets! The recession ( figures 2 and 3 ) diversification in banking: is noninterest actually! To pay to Acquire funds one way we can get some clues is by for. To those for total noninterest income assets ratio = total Cash Resources / assets 100. Cash Resources / assets * 100 determined by the collapse in securitization has been and. Attempt to preserve revenue the portion of most banks ’ use of the collapse in securitization.. The Cleveland Fedâs systemic Risk indicator Predict Stress are actually generating income smallest category 2018... A way for banks to effectively pay negative interest on deposits bank is thus better off a! Bank over another from Reports of Condition and income ( Call Reports define service charges is isolated. Money and is one form of income that is being spent to to. Observed shares of each type of revenue for banks of all sizes saw a significant portion of banks! Is not isolated to a budget because so many non interest income to total assets ratio come into play increased both absolutely and as share... Appears any impact was swamped by other factors this source of revenue, however, service charges show some differences... By issuing loans and collecting the interest rate paid by financial institutions for the changes we observe in ’. 2005 and 2018, falling from 26.2 percent of noninterest income has been, and remains, an source. This with the earning assets to total assets ratio balance for whatever period choose.